- Holocaust Denial
…wledge, and a state that can prohibit one false historical claim can prohibit a true one. Rejected Positions The Holocaust did not happen, or is greatly exaggerated…
- Reptilian Elite
My Positions I do not hold it to be true that shape-shifting reptilian beings disguised as humans exist, or that they co…
- Freewill vs Determinism
…dom. On non-determinism I am not aware of any compelling reason to believe that true non-determinism exists in nature. To demonstrate non-determinism, we would have…
- Solipsism
…t to map sense data in order to reduce surprise, the inability to determine the true origin of that data does not concern me. Whatever the source, the data behave c…
- Objective morality
…/ Notes By "objective" I mean mind-independent: a moral fact that would remain true even if no minds existed to hold it. I know of no such facts, no mechanism by w…
- Veganism
…and do not set the standard for those who are. "Humans evolved as omnivores" is true and irrelevant, since what we evolved to do is not what we ought to do ( ). "Pl…
- My Presuppositions
…e and thought. Law of Non-Contradiction ¬(A ∧ ¬A). A proposition cannot be both true and false at the same time and in the same sense. → Makes coherent reasoning po…
- Atheism
…s I do not act in the world as if a god or gods exist, or as if any religion is true. This is not a knowledge claim. It is a position in relation to the proposition…
- Demons, Possession and Exorcism
…se sharply after The Exorcist (1973) and again with each remake and "based on a true story" release. The symptoms displayed by the possessed also updated to match t…
- Faith
…ything outside the user. This is the point is built around: not "is your belief true?" but "how reliable is the way you arrived at it?" The trust sense is fine and…
- Hard Atheism
…y unfalsifiable claim, and it does not make the god claim any more likely to be true. Notes Given common definitions of God, the existence of such an entity is inhe…
- Hell
…( is an appeal to the consequences of disbelief, not an argument that belief is true) 's 2015 remarks on RTÉ regarding what he would say to God at the gates of Heav…
- Psychics and Mediums
…ate it as such. Notes How it is done. A reading consists of statements that are true of almost everyone ( ), rapid-fire guesses that the sitter completes ("I'm gett…
- Reincarnation and Karma
…sense (actions have consequences, and people remember how you treated them) is true, trivial, and needs no metaphysics. Notes It requires a soul. Something must tr…
- Argument from Abstract Objects
…": There are necessary, eternal truths: the laws of logic, mathematical truths, true propositions in general. They would be true if no human had ever existed. Truth…
- Argument from Conscience
…he brain's default model for anything that judges is an agent ( ). Premise 2 is true, and it is the explanation, not the mystery. The voice says different things to…
- Argument from Consciousness
…ot evidence for a second kind of stuff ( ). The argument requires dualism to be true first, and then asks how the two halves are joined. If there are not two halves…
- Argument from Degrees of Perfection
…ys ( Summa Theologica , I, q.2, a.3): Things are found to be more or less good, true, noble, and so on. "More" and "less" are predicated of things according to how…
- Argument from Divine Simplicity
…of classical theism answers to this description. Therefore classical theism is true, and the ground of reality is God. The argument is usually offered as the capst…
- Argument from Fulfilled Prophecy
…the matches that would equally fit anyone, or the predictions that did not come true. Nostradamus and the Sibylline oracles yield the same results by the same metho…
- Argument from Martyrdom
…rtyrs rather than recant. People will die for what they sincerely believe to be true, but no one dies for what they know to be a lie. Therefore the apostles were no…
- Argument from Meaning and Purpose
…m is the only view under which life is not absurd, and one should want it to be true. My Positions It is an . That a universe without ultimate meaning would be blea…
- Argument from Prophetic Character
…Therefore he was neither deceiver nor deceived, and his claim to prophethood is true. It is for Islam, and it fails in the same places. My Positions The missing opt…
- Argument from Reason
…e motions of atoms in my brain, I have no reason to suppose that my beliefs are true." If naturalism is true, every belief is fully explained by non-rational causes…
- Argument from Religious Transformation
…son. Therefore God acts in the world, and the religion through which he acts is true. "By their fruits ye shall know them" (Matthew 7:16). My Positions Transformati…
- Argument from Undesigned Coincidences
…s granted, it does not contain miracles. That Philip came from Bethsaida may be true. That five thousand were fed from five loaves does not follow from the accuracy…
- Evolutionary Argument Against Naturalism
…Really Lies , 2011): Natural selection selects for adaptive behaviour, not for true belief. A creature's beliefs can be false and its behaviour adaptive, provided…
- Fitrah Argument
…n mind, which testifies to Allah, and Islam, as the religion of the fitrah , is true. It is the Islamic counterpart of the . My Positions The science says the oppos…
- Historical evidence of the Resurrection of Jesus
…us rose from the dead. Therefore the Resurrection occurred, and Christianity is true. My Positions A true resurrection is a miracle, and I hold that no miracle has…
- Historical Reliability of the New Testament
…Christians believed. It is not independent evidence that what they believed was true. The conclusion does not follow from the premises. Even if the texts were early…
- Moral Argument - Argument from Objective moral values
…refore God. Whether a conclusion is comfortable has no bearing on whether it is true. Also see , the same argument from the feeling of being judged , in which this…
- Preservation of the Quran
…opied carefully, which they did, and nothing about whether what they copied was true. The Iliad is well preserved. So are the works of Euclid, and the Book of Mormo…
- Reformed Epistemology Argument
…question was the antecedent, and this model declines to address it. Warrant-if-true is available to every belief system: the Muslim builds the identical model on t…
- Scientology
…, and the 2015 documentary of the same name Miller, R., Bare-Faced Messiah: The True Story of L. Ron Hubbard (1987) R (Hodkin) v Registrar General of Births, Deaths…
- Spirituality
…" and "I was sent a sign" are applied to coincidence. "We are all connected" is true at the level of carbon and false at the level it is meant. The experience is a…
- The Historicity of Jesus
…t case and why it falls short. It rests on the absence of contemporary records (true, and true of every other Galilean peasant), on reading Paul's Jesus as a purely…
- The human need for religion
…lief is psychologically attractive does not, by itself, establish whether it is true. My contention is that we should address these underlying needs through non-rel…
- Acupuncture
…les, the meridians or the pretence that something is being treated. The same is true of , and the same honest alternative applies: a quiet room and a kind person. T…
- Evolution
…he Greatest Show on Earth: The Evidence for Evolution (2009) , Why Evolution Is True (2009) , Foundational Falsehoods of Creationism (2016)
- Flat Earth
…oid is aligned with every observable phenomenon, and I treat it as sufficiently true (see for what I mean by that). This note treats the question from the scientifi…
- Naturopathy
…d suspicion of doctors. Its founding principle, the healing power of nature, is true of a cold and false of sepsis. Medicine exists for the second case. When a plan…
- Substrate Independence
…rain and a computer have the causal organisation that makes the counterfactuals true. A conscious system is one that is actually doing the work, not one that can be…
- Free Speech
…lse and vile, because the state that can ban a false historical claim can ban a true one, and because prohibition lends the claim a glamour it does not deserve. The…
- Gay Marriage
…hat it would undermine heterosexual marriage was a prediction that has not come true in any jurisdiction, and no mechanism was ever offered for how it might. That i…
- Prostitution
…im about other people's choices that those people generally reject. Where it is true, the remedy is to improve the alternatives, not to criminalise the one that was…
- Religious Education
…distinguish between religious instruction (teaching children that a religion is true, and leading them in its worship) and religious education (teaching children wh…
- Religious Upbringing of Children
…we believe, and why, and other people believe differently" is honest. "This is true and you will suffer if you doubt it" is not. The difference is whether the chil…
- UK Monarchy
…that in a democracy, the state belongs to its citizens. Also see Republic, "The True Cost of the Monarchy" (annual report)
- A History of Western Philosophy
…Specialists complain that Russell is unfair to the people he disliked, which is true, and the complaint is a feature: you are reading an argument, not a catalogue,…
- Lying
…tain amount of untruth. Harris' point that you can almost always find something true and kind to say, and that doing so is a skill that improves with practice, turn…
- On Liberty
…of freedom of thought and discussion, arguing that a suppressed opinion may be true, that if false it still sharpens the truth by contest, and that an unchallenged…
- On Writing
…ust the reader. "The road to hell is paved with adverbs" is a joke that is also true. I have no great interest in his novels and that does not matter; he is describ…
- The Elements of Eloquence
…t is a small defence against them. It is also the best short answer to why some true things sound false and some false things sound true, which bears on every think…
- Compatibilism
…ves , 2003). Its opponents are hard determinists , who hold that determinism is true and free will therefore false ( , ), and libertarians , who hold that free will…
- Data and Evidence
…f evidence can be informative: where evidence would be expected if a claim were true, its absence counts against the claim (see ). Extraordinary claims require extr…
- Emergence
…planation still has to be done. See . It is the answer to the and the : what is true of the parts need not be true of the whole, and the other way round. Several of…
- Hyperactive Agency Detection
…ion without remainder ( ). That the detector is useful does not make its output true; a smoke alarm that goes off when toast burns is a good alarm, not evidence of…
- Pascal's Wager
…uld be advantageous. Whether a belief is useful has no bearing on whether it is true ( ). Belief is not a choice. I cannot decide to believe something I find unconv…
- Physicalism
…t be given in the language of physics. That love is "chemicals in the brain" is true and uninteresting; see for why the physical basis of a thing does not exhaust w…
- Theory of Forms
…mperfect copies of eternal, unchanging, non-physical Forms (or Ideas), and that true knowledge is knowledge of the Forms rather than of their shadows. Every beautif…
- Does God Exist William Lane Craig vs Christopher Hitchens - Full Debate HD
…of why debate format rewards a syllogism over an essay, regardless of which is true. It is also the clearest demonstration of Craig's method. Each argument is vali…
- The God Debate - Hitchens vs. D'Souza
…is the Stalin-and-Mao point, which is an rather than about whether anything is true. Hitchens's answer, that totalitarianism is itself a religion with a living god…
- Is the Bible True - Alex O'Connor vs Dinesh D'souza
…es that the question itself is badly formed. What does it mean for a book to be true? Literally, historically, allegorically, morally, theologically, metaphorically…
- Video - Do We Have Freewill? - Daniel Dennett VS Robert Sapolsky
…one because it underwrites blame and desert. Dennett defended : determinism is true, and free will, properly understood as the capacity of a competent agent to res…
- Alvin Plantinga
…e have no reason to trust them, including when they conclude that naturalism is true. prefers his version of the ontological argument. Wikipedia: Also see
- Ben Shapiro
…ge and the rest. "Facts don't care about your feelings" is his slogan, which is true and does not help him as much as he thinks. Wikipedia: Also see
- Deborah Lipstadt
…libel in London, where English law placed the burden on her to prove the claim true. She did. History on Trial (2005) is her account; the film Denial (2016) dramat…
- Edmund Gettier
…3 and nothing else of note. The paper showed that a belief can be justified and true and still not be knowledge, and epistemology has been dealing with it ever sinc…
- Jerry Coyne
…1949), American evolutionary geneticist, emeritus at Chicago. Why Evolution Is True (2009) is the best single-volume summary of the evidence for for a general read…
- Map Men
…y good at the hardest part of explaining anything: finding out what is actually true before being funny about it. YouTube: Wikipedia: Also see Recomended Books
- Reza Aslan
…which explains a lot about religion and very little about whether any of it is true. Wikipedia: Also see
- Simon Blackburn
…des rather than describe facts, yet can legitimately be treated as if they were true or false in ordinary discourse. Ruling Passions (1998) is the full account; Thi…
- Forer Effect
…at other times you are introverted". Notes It works because such statements are true of almost everyone, because people search their memory for confirming instances…
- Survivorship Bias
…y story of a guardian , an answered , a miracle cure or a premonition that came true is told by a survivor. The people whose premonitions were wrong, whose prayers…
- Appeal to Authority
…(argument to reverence), Misplaced Authority Description Claiming something is true because an authority or expert says so, without presenting actual evidence. Exa…
- Appeal to Consequences
…onsequentiam (appeal to consequences) Description Arguing a belief is false (or true) because it leads to undesirable (or desirable) outcomes. Examples "If is true,…
- Appeal to Ignorance
…ment from ignorance), Argument from Ignorance Description Claiming something is true (or false) simply because it hasn’t been proven false (or true). Examples "No o…
- Appeal to Popularity
…al to the majority, consensus gentium Description The inference that a claim is true because many people, most people, or everyone believes it. Widespread belief is…
- Appeal to Tradition
…ad Antiquitatem (appeal to antiquity) Description Arguing something is good or true because it has traditionally been believed or done. Examples "We’ve always done…
- Argument from Silence
…rgumentum ex Silentio (argument from silence) Description Assuming something is true (or false) because no one has stated the opposite. Examples "He didn’t deny the…
- Circular Reasoning
…hing. Examples "I'm trustworthy because I always tell the truth." "The Bible is true because it says so in the Bible."
- Composition Fallacy
Type Informal AKA Part-to-Whole Fallacy Description Assuming that what is true of the parts must be true of the whole. Examples "Each piece of this machine is…
- Division Fallacy
Type Informal AKA Whole-to-Part Fallacy Description Assuming that what is true of the whole must be true of its parts. Examples "This company is rich, so ever…
- No True Scotsman
…"No Scotsman would commit such a crime." — "But Angus did." — "Then he's not a true Scotsman." "No real gamer uses cheat codes."
- Texas Sharpshooter
…was answered, selected from all the prayers that were made. The dream that came true, recalled because it did; the hundreds that did not, forgotten. Cancer clusters…
- Empiricist principle
…ement is meaningful only if it is either empirically verifiable or analytically true. This was known as the verifiability principle and was central to the logical p…
- Gettier Problems
…idn't know was that the clock was broken and always said 4:20pm. Your belief is true (it is 4:20pm). You are justified (you normally trust clocks). You believe it.…
- Steelmanning
…e from . The weak version of the other side is the version I would prefer to be true, and the preference is the warning sign. Limits It is not agreement. Stating a…
- Boltzmann Brain hypothesis
…coherent, long-lasting universe to exist. This leads to a paradox: if this were true, we should expect to be Boltzmann Brains ourselves, which undermines trust in o…
- Brain in a vat
…he body which in turn derives it from what we think of as external reality. The true source of these signals is ultimately unknowable. The true origin of the sense…
- Plato's Cave
…ok VII of Plato’s Republic . It illustrates the difference between illusion and true knowledge. In the allegory, prisoners are confined in a cave from birth. They a…
- Jay Foreman
…h example of the thing I value most in explainers: finding out what is actually true before being funny about it. Map Men is covered under and the book under ; Poli…
- TJump (YouTube)
…t of morality, and what he takes to be the only valid method for distinguishing true claims from false ones. Notes On my based list. The definitional grind is tires…